tv [untitled] August 10, 2013 1:00pm-1:31pm PDT
metal shop separates an alley and the apartment complex behind it so we've never had an issue, we kind of naibl with the neighbors back there, but we've never heard of one complaint yet. >> the skylight is in the assembly area though? >> it is, [inaudible] throughout the building. >> i'm done, but bear in mind, you might have to cap those. >> and we anticipate that as well, we're in it for the long hall, so we are definitely considering spray acoustics. inger >> i love the welding shop. >> sxit's pumping right now, come on by. >> i think commissioner hyde had some comments or questions. >> did you approach any neighborhood organizations or not for profit ins the area to talk about this? >> we did. >> can you tell me what they were. >> sure. we are an extension of the
shell space programming, we've kept all of the programming, we didn't kick artists out of the facility, we didn't kick any of the long term tenants that we had which our longest term tenant on a weekly basis, the as t*ek tans group. >> what i'm talking about is going to these groups and saying, hey, we're applying for this permit and, you know, you're a neighborhood association so we wanted to talk to you about this, did you make any -- >> so far, we've done the san francisco green business certification, so we're about two thirds of the way through that process with them. >> okay. so, -- >> and beyond that, this is -- i need to point out that this is -- shell space had a poe the entire time of its existence, so that's what being part of that collective -- >> so, it's not a new poe really. >> okay, i understand. >> yeah.
>> but we did outreach to neighborhoods just by foot and there's more than 40 people in my circuit and we get out and about and work in the community in every regard. we keep up the gardens, what is the gardens? >> esperonza gardens. >> i was wondering if you could please inform me what kind of benefits your neighborhood outreach you feel have brought you? >> i think the big part of it is our business plan of what we do moving forward. we are still considering ourselves just getting into this space right now especially with the turn of events, the slow down of our business, it's been a big part of our plan to have community benefit be part of our business plan, so give back programs, grant programs, upkeep on the gardens, art program. >> with did limited program, i believe that you guys are really good people and you have
really good hearts and i'm glad something that is going into shell space that is so community oriented but the idea is to go out and tell people that you're getting a limited live permit, so have you done that? >> well, again, we've had this limited live permit throughout -- >> it's not a place of entertainment permit? >> it's a place of entertainment or live? >> so, this is a continuation of an old poe? >> but none of those collective neighbors are still here and we're the one who are fighting the financial bullet. >> so, i'm confused as to what this means so i'm going to bring that up later, so thanks. >> okay, sure. >> alright, so are there any other questions or comments from commissioners? if not, we can open it up to the public comment, and if mission station has any comments?
>> so much going on in the mission. >> so, commissioners, i'm sure you're all familiar with the issue of shell space, it goes back many years, our file is very extensive on this place, we could probably write an action movie on all the exciting things that have come out of the space over the years. when the new team came forward and met with us at mission station, i have to admit, we were very excited about moving on in a positive way, moving beyond all the history that has occurred there, that it's been challenging from a public safety perspective, and i believe that this team really wanted to come in and create a new direction.
i apologize if i keep referring to them as shell space, is it inner mission? >> yes. >> that being said, i think that what happened was almost immediately we were seeing some of the same activity that had happened previously with the shell space ownership. that is there was a lot of activity in the area of applying for abc one day permits, there was a lot of activity as it relates to third party promoters coming in, 18 and over type entertainment and so on, so really, nothing changed from our perspective, and in fact, we as i recall and i don't have the file, investigated and discovered there were events where alcohol was being served that was not
permitted, so ultimately, and i think the captain used some words but i'm sure it wasn't in the line of excitement for this place, he wanted us to discontinue issuing one day abc for this venue, and i'm not sure any will be issued going forward because we're not sure that what they're presenting is what they're actually doing. my concern is the third party promoters, the 18 and over entertainment, particularly when there's alcohol being served, so we have submitted some conditions, number 8 and 9, i think i circled those. we're very concerned about third party promoters, we want to make sure they're legitimate, that they're invested in the safety of the
venue, that they notify us in advance when they're going to be engaging these third party promoters and that they prove that they have insurance, general liability insurance for that special event. the alcohol thing is a separate thing, as far as the one day stuff, we'll have to address that separately with them because it is a separate issue from the entertainment permit, so we're not oppose today the entertainment permit being issued with these conditions as long as they understand them and they're going the take them seriously and we're not going to issue abc one day permits and allow them to have an 18 and over entertainment venue. so, i was hoping maybe they could comment about that. >> officer bruk n*er, if you don't mind, i don't know if any of the commissioners that sit on this commission today remembers any of that shell
space stuff because -- so, there's just two of us because that was the time [inaudible] and i've directed to staff, i'm not sure that -- have we had any notification of incidents at 20150 bryant street in the last 15 years for instance that you know of? >> well, i'm sorry, i didn't bring the old shelf space file with me, but it's been quite some time with those activities that inner mission was doing, moved to another location all together when they had a problem with the capacity and the fire issues so i would have to go back to be really specific on my answer, but it's not been a year for sure to say. >> as far as one day permits and i know the alu is in the audience, but maybe you can correct me if i'm wrong.
is it not true that a space can only have so many in a given year or a given month? it's like one a month per address or something like that, is that not true? >> well, ultimately, it's the captain's decision as to whether or not he or she will issue the permit at all. it's entirely on the captain, so they're not obligated to issue a certain number. >> but is there an abc ordinance that you are aware of that limits one-day permits for any location? >> yes, there is. >> alright. so, that even in, you know, the worst case scenario, they can om get a certain amount of permits per year? >> well, not necessarily. they change the non-profit from one to another and they continue applying, if i'm mistaken, alu can correct me on this matter, but it may not be sloshed to the actual physical address, rather the non-profit at that address. that may be a technical thing.
>> we should look into that and see exactly what that is. >> ultimately the captain will decide, it doesn't matter if there's one or two or 10 non-profits involved, if there are a significant number of applications and associated with those applications, we've had a significant number of public safety problems, then he'll just simply not approve the permits going forward. >> okay, but -- so, correct me if i'm wrong, our permit really is not, although we try to go side by side with the abc, we can issue a permit whether there's an abc license or not and we can decide whether to issue one going forward? >> it's all interrelated, they're the last entertainment, advertised venues that they had there that ended up getting cancelled because they had no permits, they were going to
have a live burlesque nude show and there was alcohol at that event, they didn't submit that to us as such, they submitted to us as this was this amazing non-profit that they were going to benefit but in reality, they didn't tell us that it's a burlesque show that they're having, and that makes a difference to the entertainment permit as well so, we just want transparency, we want to know exactly what's happening and until we do and until we're comfortable with it, i don't believe the captain's issuing any one day abc permits. >> so, burlesque is not necessarily nude, as i know, i don't think this commission is aware of this problem at this
address in the last 12 months and maybe longer and if you guys have seen problems with it and we don't know about it, it's on you to let us know, right. >> commissioners, i understand there hasn't been a lot of activity at this address, there's been no entertainment, that's why you wouldn't hear of any problems. >> so, we can't assume that it's going to be bad if there hasn't been much. >> i'm excited about the new ownership and moving on in a positive way and putting -- and working together with them, so that we can come up with a reasonable and transparent way to work with them. we want to understand what's happening. we don't believe that that has happened so far. it's kind of the same thing that happened before. >> okay, thank you. >> thank you. >> i have a question, officer. >> go ahead, commissioner lee? >> has the police met with
their security team yet? >> officer buck n*er? >> their proposed security team. >> i don't know if the permit officer at mission station has met with them, you know officer parker is working with this and i'm filling in today and i'm giving you what i know from my memory. i think she is working with them, right? >> [inaudible]. >> right. >> where does that say that has to happen? >> i'm just curious, they have to have security. >> but they don't have to meet with the commission: it's not with the commission yet. >> let's take public comment and then we can discuss whatever we need to after that. are there any public comment on this? you guys aren't the public. nope. seeing none, public comment is closed. the matter is now with the commission. >> so, i just want to say that for those of you who don't know, shelf space was
problematic years ago, they had a bunch of parties that ran out of control for a lot of reasons including the naivety of the people who ran the party and is the people who came in there. there hasn't been a lot of activity there now, so i think that from my perspective, i do believe that a space that -- a venue that provides space for artists of all types, kids of all ages to come in and whether they have alcohol or not is important in the actual -- cultural activity in our
community, if they can do 18 and over, that would be great. i understand these people should be straight up with the police at all times and not embellish or not leave out information when applying for permits with the station because the station sends patrol cars out and so if you're not 100% truthful, they're going to know it and you won't have the courtesy of having them on your side going forward, but i do believe this is an important space. i'm excited that it's being developed by a new group that seeps to be working really hard and investing a bunch of cash into it and i think that that speaks to their desire to have success. so, having said that, to that end -- >> can i make a comment. >> i would like to make a motion to approve this permit including our good neighbor
policy and with regard to the police conditions -- >> excuse me, commissioner joseph, so when they first filled out their application, it was several months ago and the police conditions that i just handed to officer buck n*er had 11 conditions on it, he was talking about 8 and 9 which are not on the new conditions that we received yesterday. so, i think that the conditions that he was talking about had to do with third party promoters and getting liability insurance, so if i can ask officer buck n*er to give me those back, -- >> are these conditions or not? >> the conditions that you have in your folder were submitted yesterday. >> so, they're the newest ones, they're the most recent. >> so, why would we not use the most recent conditions? >> you can, i'm just trying to clarify that he had been discussing -- i just wanted you to know that he was talking
about the third party conditions, and those are not on the conditions you have that are the most recent. >> and i would like to say that when tim eiker came here and was asked to do the same thing, we said that was probably not something that the venue should be responsible to and have that insurance attached to their permit before. >> right, because -- i have to assume that they have general liability insurance to cover their venue for trip and fall. if they choose to have a promoter, doesn't our promoter legislation say the promoter has to have insurance, do you know? the promoter legislation? >> it does not say that. >> if they choose to allow a promoter in there without additional insurance, they would be the first sued, so that's on them. if they want to -- if they want to force a promoter to get insurance and name them, i mean, that's what i would do if
it was my venue, but i mean, i think that's a business decision on their part and if they want to take the hit if something happens, that's their decision. i agree with commissioner hyde, so in finishing making my motion, so i am looking at the most current police conditions and i don't see anything that i would eliminate except -- once again, i want to talk to officer parker about repeating stuff that's in our good neighbor policy, anyway, that's my motion, so my motion is to approve with our good neighbor policy and the 9 police commissions. >> alright, is there a second? >> i would like to make a second and an amendment.
so, i would second the motion and i would like to ask as an amendment that we strike number 3 as it's redundant with the good neighbor policy and then i have a question about number 4, and management shall enforce cantilevering provisions of san francisco mp c-1 21 and cooperate with sfpd regarding enforcement actions. i've never seen that before as a -- and to me, they have to manage crowds within 100 feet and so that i think, you know, they already are required to manage their prouds within 100 feet, so this to me sounds also a bit redundant and i would like the strike that. >> so, i have no problem accepting your amendment for number 3, however, i don't know
if this is the proper code section, i know this commission worked hard to get an antiloiterbacking piece of legislation through to get the people to get to move on and call police, and it is a tool that we use to protect patrons from becoming victims, and we -- i mean, to officer parker's credit, we find very often that venues are not aware of our codes and don't know they have this power, so i have no problem with that. it's a tool for the venue. it's not an extra burden. i think that that police condition should remain and that we should -- since we don't work to familiarize our venues of that particular tool, i think that this might help to do that in my opinion, so i'll accept number 3 and reject number 4. >> so, the motion is to approve
the permit with the good neighbor policy and all the police conditions except for number 3. and there's a second. >> and i'll accept that change. >> alright, so is there any other discussion or questions from the commission? >> i just have a comment, that's it. regardless, audrey, if they're not required to talk to the police, my thing is they're responsible -- i'm for them to change -- the space adds problems, i always encourage your present security to have a conversation with the permit officer, that's all i'm saying, whether it's required or not by this commission, i'm always into improved maintenance because you don't want to have a problem later. >> can i ask staff a clarifying question, so if they were to make major changes adding egresses to the venue, do they
have to reapply at any point? >> no, it aos an occupancy load. >> if they do something that substantially changes the physicality of the space, we would expect them to notify us at minimum, the permit has the occupancy number on it, so in light of them improving their occupancy, they'd want to change that. would it come before this commission? not likely unless we consider it a major amendment. >> so, it's a minor amendment. >> given the circumstances you described. >> okay, great, helpful. so, any other comments before we take it to a vote? no? alright. can we do the vote now? >> okay, so this is to grant the permit with the police conditions and the good neighbor policy striking number 3 from the police conditions. commissioner camp knoll ly? >> aye. >> commissioner lee? >> commissioner joseph? >> aye. >> commissioner hyde? >> aye. >> commissioner tan? >> aye. >> great, that is approved.
we are going move on, good luck, thank you for coming. >> sorry, but i have to be excused, i have a commitment that i have to go to. >> alright, so let the record show that commissioner joseph is heading out. we're going to move back to item -- the original item 3 which was the report from the check t*if director, go ahead director kane? >> thank you very much, how are we doing on time? i'm going to be as quick as i can. hi, commissioner, it's been a long time since i've seen you, i don't think there's been a meeting for quite some time, so welcome back, the status of the broadway cbd, i want to remind you of that, that it was formed
and the date the final approval was june 5th, we're hoping that this moves towards some perm nant change on the broadway corridor, the cbd will assess levees on property owners totaling 500 thousand dollars, so it's not a tremendous amount but those are the kind of funds that will be cleaned up for security, clean up and marketing, so if you are watching, broadway, at all, hopefully you'll see positive change and that will be a part of it. the department also wanted to let you know, we filed our quarterly reports regarding complaints related to section 1070 as you might recall, there were a whole bunch of reporting requirements put on the commission in about the end of 2009 and we are required to do quarterly reports so we did submit those to the clerk of the board in mid july.
i wanted to review some of -- i think all of you might have been at the entertainment commission's 10th anniversary party that we had, we turned 10 years old on july 1, we celebrated with about 500 of our closest friends at the drake, we wanted to say thanks to commissioner lee to, to sight and sound and to staff for sponsoring and helping out. i think we had a good turn-out, it was a lot of fun and i hope everyone got their spin art and we have it in the office if you forgot it. we also wanted to let you know, i'm not sure if the commission was aware, we did our first every legislative aide happy hour event last wednesday on the 31 of july, staff invited them from all 11 districts to happy hour down the extreme and
the intent was to ensure that the board had some familiarity with the entertainment commission and how they could help our office and is to remind them of their uses in the limited live performance as well as one time events and give them the opportunity to ask staff and just get to know our faces and ask any questions so we had a fairly good turn-out based on the fact that we were a day after recess, so much like elementary school, the board of supervisors has recessed during the summer, and so some of them took off, but we got a good turn-out i think. i also attached behind this memo the commission terms and seats, if you saw that, this has come up -- it comes up quite a bit, there's some turn-over of your seat and wanted to make sure everyone's aware of who is where and when your terms are up, so keep that
for your -- hopefully that's the most updated one for your reference. upcoming, we're planning a health care workshop on september 9th, there's something called the actor's fund based out of l.a. and they're awarded a federal grant to be the provider of health care reform, outreach and education to the performing arts and entertainment community in san francisco, they offered to do a workshop about what is commonly spoken of as obama care in the nicest way, so we secured the auditorium for september 9th we created an event, and if you haven't seen it, we're going to do a straight e-mail to people's boxes shortly, it's going to be free and an hour and a half and i think it's really important that people understand that covered
california website is up and running and people need to be ensured by the 1st of next year the covered california website is going to be working october 1 to enroll people and we don't know what's going to happen with healthy san francisco but we think that it's a good start to understanding everything as early as possible, so please invite everyone you know. lastly, we have -- kami has drafted an annual report, we have not been good with annual reports so we're trying to get into the groove so we drafted it and we're hope tog get a final version completed by the end of the month, we asked commissioner perez to help us with some graphic design work since he's good at it as you know, so i was hoping he would be here to corner him into
giving me a final date but he's not, so again, we're going to shoot for the end of august to have that completed and submitted to everybody so that we can talk about our great work to everyone in a really pretty way. there are no corrective actions to report, but something i didn't write down in the memo, what i want today do was introduce ben van hoot, he's going to tell you what his long involved title is, but he was hired by the mayor's office by the economic and workforce development to do that kind of economic work around night life and entertainment, so i want to let him do the honors. >> good evening, most of the long title was summed up in jocelyn's description, ben van hoot from the office of economic workforce and development, i am excited to work with you to support the growth and vitality of the
nightlife and entertainment industry and i'm already working on a number of already i think very exciting projects with the entertainment commission to expand business awareness of available performance as well as the limited live performance permit as well as some other measures to garner feedback from the stray -- industry about that their concerns and challenges and develop some new policy strategies based on that feedback, so thank you. >> welcome aboard. >> thank you. >> sorry, so that concludes my report. ron is here as you know, and he submitted a written report, this is his first time presenting in front of you i think, so be kind. [laughter]. >> good afternoon, commissioners, it's been a long time since we've last actually communicated here, so thers